Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) is the most cited constitutional decision in Indian law. It sat with thirteen judges, the largest bench the Supreme Court has ever assembled, and it produced one of the closest results: a 7:6 majority. This analysis sets out the question, the holding, and why the doctrine it created still shapes constitutional litigation.

The question before the court

The petition began as a challenge to Kerala land reform laws. It became a contest over a larger question: is Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution unlimited?

Two earlier decisions pulled in different directions. In Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965), the court treated constitutional amendments as beyond the reach of Article 13. In Golaknath (1967), a majority held the opposite: an amendment was “law”, so it could not take away fundamental rights.

Parliament answered Golaknath with the Twenty-fourth Amendment, which restated the amending power in Article 368:

Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, Parliament may in exercise of its constituent power amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of this Constitution in accordance with the procedure laid down in this article.

Article 368(1), Constitution of India

The holding

The majority reached three conclusions that matter today:

  1. Golaknath was overruled. A constitutional amendment is not “law” under Article 13.
  2. The Twenty-fourth Amendment was valid. Parliament’s amending power is wide and extends to every part of the Constitution, including fundamental rights.
  3. That power has an implied limit. Parliament may amend, but it may not alter the basic structure or framework of the Constitution.

The judges did not agree on a closed list of “basic features”. Different opinions mentioned supremacy of the Constitution, republican and democratic government, secularism, separation of powers and federalism, among others.1

Why a 7:6 split still binds

Reading the case is hard because there are eleven separate opinions. The binding principle comes from a short “View of the Majority” statement signed by nine judges at the end of the case. Students should read that statement first, then the individual opinions.

Issue Outcome Practical effect
Is an amendment “law” under Art. 13? No (Golaknath overruled) Amendments are tested against the basic structure, not Part III alone
Scope of Art. 368 Wide, covers all provisions Fundamental rights can be amended
Limit on amendment Basic structure cannot be destroyed Courts retain review over amendments

Later applications

The doctrine was soon used to strike down amendments. In Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) it was applied to an election-related amendment. In Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980), the court held that limited amending power is itself a basic feature.

Takeaways for practitioners

  • When challenging a constitutional amendment, frame the argument around an identifiable basic feature, not a single article.
  • When citing Kesavananda, cite the majority statement and the specific opinion you rely on.
  • The doctrine applies to constitutional amendments. Ordinary legislation is tested against the Constitution’s express provisions.

This is a sample article for demonstration. Replace or delete it before launch.

Footnotes

  1. The list of basic features has grown case by case. No single judgment is treated as exhaustive. ↩